Pages

Showing posts with label Thesis Writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thesis Writing. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Of quotes, paraphrases, and reports

Journals don't usually require a certain number of words; they have a maximum allowed number. However, within the community, a write-up of around 6,000 words is a recognized minimum. When I used to debate, the standard speech was 7 minutes, give or take 15 seconds. The Grand Chancellor of our debate explained during training that anything more can get boring. Anything less is insubstantial.


There are reasons why there's the expected number of words. However, you don't just write anything you want or get snippets of quotes to fill those numbers up.


Another phenomenon in writing is the idea of originality, achieved by ensuring you cite a lot. This can get quite paradoxical and confusing if one does not know the process. If you cite, the material isn't yours, even if you put the in-text and the bibliographic reference. So how is it original? Let's go through understanding the strategies in writing to address these principles.


Structure

As discussed in the previous posts, your writing should always have a thesis. The entire manuscript, your paper, has one. The main argument. It doesn't end there. When you outline, you establish sub-thesis, sub-arguments, or sub-topics supporting the central argument. These then become the sections of your paper. Within each section, each paragraph should support the sub-thesis, sub-argument, or sub-topic of that section. The structure of each paragraph has a central topic. The topic sentence. Anything else within that paragraph should either support or explain the topic sentence. It is from here that you generate your citations.


When you illustrate a point or prove that the point is real, you use examples. You can use hypotheticals - imaginary scenarios. That's okay, but if you use hypotheticals throughout the paper, this isn't research anymore; it is a writer imagining things. You use examples from the world of experience. Either your collected data or the data from analyzed, collected, or reported data by other published works. So, you cite. When you need to explain, you narrow down (deduct) or work up your ideas (induct) one sentence at a time. The deductive process means breaking down a generalized idea and relaying the component parts. Inductive is a reverse. You bring specific ideas, leading to a generalized one.


Take, for example, you are writing about how internet trolls are muddying the Duterte-ICC discourse. That's the central topic of the paragraph. You then explain different ways that a discourse can get muddied. Take note, I use the word explain. That means that you are defining or walking the reader through the process. Using examples is a different case. You can mix those up. 


That one was deductive. How about an inductive one? Let's say you argue in the paragraph that the sovereignty issue in the Duterte-ICC discourse is one of the factors in the muddied discourse. That's something specific. You can then proceed to explain the essence of sovereignty. Then, explain the issue at the ICC. Then, relate the troll narratives. Then, synthesize how each of these elements leads toward a muddied discourse.


You cite each piece of evidence you use to support your argument. For each explanation, you might have to refer to ideas from reputable references, so you also cite them. In the previous sample, in explaining the issue of the ICC, unless you were there hearing what happened, you will have to cite the news or, better yet, a press release from ICC (the difference would be that the news is a secondary source while the press release can be primary). If you were there in the field, you mention it, thus proving your point.


Matter

The evidence you use can take the common form of quotes and paraphrases. Some forget to report. Some forget what a precis is. Let's learn how to use them.


Quotes

We use quotes to preserve the essence of what the original author said and to engage with their ideas within our text. When you write, begin with a budget on quotes in mind and use technical terms that may be original to the author. Nowadays, originality is measured through similarity match percentage using text-computing software on plagiarism; the most popular is TurnITIn. Even without such software, professional readers will notice that a 10-page paper is half quotes and half the writer's text. Sometimes, it's obviously even more. So, you minimize the quotes and reserve them for essential statements. Then, if you use a lot of technical words that the writer uses, this will reduce your quote budget. Always remember that a direct quote will require not just the author and date for the in-text citation but you will also need to mention the page number/s. I.e. (Castillo, 2023, p. 8).


Paraphrase

A paraphrase is a rephrasing of the original statement while retaining its essence. It is the number one method of avoiding plagiarism. Some people paraphrase everything, which can get clunky. But it's safe. A vast vocabulary is useful. A thesaurus can also be helpful. Another thing you need to remember is the perspective or the mode of how to say the original statement. Depending on the writing style (APA, Chicago, etc.). You should also mention the page number in the in-text citation.


Precis

A precis is a summary of the idea expressed through a rephrased statement. You won't need to mention the page number, primarily if the precis refers to an entire book or article. If you are referring to a section, mention the page number/s. 


Reports

Sometimes, you will see that the reference you are referring to is also referring to another work. It's best to include the reference of both works if you refer to such. For example, Castillo (2023) referred to Knight (1603) in defining the idea of misogyny. Why not just refer to Knight? In this case, there's more than one reason. The primary is that you might not have known about Knight without Castillo. Practice ethics! Second, Knight's reference is too old; Castillo adds a certain degree of dated relevance.  What if Knight was only one or a couple of years back? Refer to the first reason.


This is not the only way to report. You can use a precis to report not just the author's idea but also what the author did. Castillo (2023) content-analyzed film. In Castillo's (2023) content analysis of Harry Potter, he found that... 

Another thing to report is conversations. When authors cite, they engage with other writers. Sometimes, not just one. So you can report that. Castillo (2023) arrived at an understanding of misogyny through a review of works such as those of Knight (1603), Bishop (1888), and Pawn (2022). Note the difference between simply paraphrasing and lining them up in sequence. A report is yours, not anybody else's. That adds both originality and style to your writing.


No need to fill in numbers

Given these guidelines, you won't have to worry about filling in the numbers. You may have to trim your writing because of the breadth of what you wrote. It will also help both you and your reader because you will have expressed what you need to express, hopefully, in a clear way.














Sunday, February 16, 2025

Maximize your word processor

I haven't had the time to blog for quite some time since it's all-hands-on-deck for me to finalized my dissertation. Now that I've completed my manuscript, here's some important reminders for anyone who is writing.

Methodical steps in writing often get things done smoothly and right. I hate wasting time and effort only to have to redo things. What can we do to organize our writing? Please note that what I share in this blog post is on using Microsoft Word. Other word processing software may have different processes.


Using automated cross-references 

First off is captioning your figures. I hope you already uses the automated numbering of captions for figures. This is especially helpful if you have a large number of figures or if you figures across different chapters or sections of your manuscript. 

But what if you have to add a new figure between two already existing figures in separate pages? For example, your page 10 has Figure 1 and your page 15 has Figure two and you need to add a new one on page 11? Or you have Figure 3 on page 16 and would like to move it to page 11? Just click the inserted figure, then choose INSERT CAPTION. Sometimes the Figure numbers will automatically adjust, if they don't then just RIGHT-CLICK on the figure number and choose UPDATE FIELD. Just repeat these on the affected ones as necessary.

But why use this when you can just type the words Figure and the corresponding number? These automated devices through the word processor can help with other parts of your writing. One is through cross-references. When you need to refer to such automated sets of items in your manuscript, what you need to do is insert a cross reference. 

Example, you have Figure 1. Then you are writing and your refer to it, such as saying "Figure 1 shows the conceptual framework." Or the conceptual framework (Figure 1)..." 

Don't type the text "Figure 1" !!!!!

Rather use the cross-reference feature of MS Word. There are two locations where the cross-reference button is located (see the photos below).


CROSS-REFERENCE button through the REFERENCE tab


CROSS-REFERENCE button through the INSERT tab

Instead of writing "Figure 1" you should place the cursor on the location in the document then click the cross-reference button. This will open the window below.


CROSS-REFERENCE window

The three important parts of this window are REFERENCE TYPE, FOR WHICH NUMBERED ITEM, and INSERT REFERENCE TO.

There are several reference types. Since y ou are writing about a figure, choose FIGURE for REFERENCE TYPE. The under FOR WHICH NUMBERED ITEM will change into the list of your existing figures. Click the figure you want to refer to, then for INSERT REFERENCE TO, choose ONLY LABEL AND NUMBER. The label and number are the text Figure and the corresponding number. Once done, click the INSERT button below the window. This will result into an automated text that will read "Figure x" depending on the number of the figure you are referring to. Because the text is cross-reference to the actual figure, then any changes in numbering that may happen, whether while you are writing or if you require revision, then the text can easily be adjust to match the changes. Just like with the caption, if you need to adjust the numbers, just RIGHT-CLICK on the figure number in the paragraph and choose UPDATE FIELD.


Anotrher useful part of cross-reference is the capacity to have auto-updating references to parts of your manuscript. Top tier journals have tables of compliance for revisions. This makes the revisions easier to track. I applied this to my own dissertation so that the comments during my proposal are summed up in a table that I placed in the appendix. A part of this table is a column of the comunts, a column for the name/s of commiittee/panel members who gave the comment, then a column of what I did in response, and a third column pointing towards the page where the revision is. This makes your work clean and professional. But what if a change in the manuscript adjusts the page numbers? Would you have to recheck each page number that you wrote? 

Well, that's sloppy. What you should be doing is use cross-reference. Regarding this, you are referring to page numbers and not to figure numbers. So, for REFERENCE TYPE, choose NUMBERED ITEM. The list on FOR WHICH NUMBERED ITEM will be similar to the ones listed above the headings (more on these later) you used. Choose which part you need to refer to (such as your framework, or literature review). For INSERT REFERENCE TO, just choose PAGE NUMBER. Clicking  INSERT will insert the page number that even hyperlinks to the specific page. And just like any of the cross-references, RIGHT-CLICK on the number and choose UPDATE FIELD. to allow it to automatically adjust if ever the pages in your manuscript has changed.

BOOKMARK button through the INSERT tab

Sometimes, you have to refer to a page containing a specific paragraph. If your manuscript uses paragraph numbers, then you can use that. But that's seldom used. What you can do is go to the paragraph, highlight it, then click BOOKMARK (see the photo above). This will record the paragraph as a specific item of bookmark. In fact, when you click the BOOKMARK button, you will be prompted to name the bookmark. One you have done all the bookmarks you need. You can select bookmark as REFERENCE TYPE. The list on FOR WHICH NUMBERED ITEM will now change to the list of bookmark names you made. Choose the one you need to refer to and choose PAGE NUMBER for INSERT REFERENCE TO. 


Using the automated table of contents and automated list of figures


Writing the table of contents can be tedious and making sure that the page numbers do refer to the correct page locations. It's again a sloppy work if you do this manually. All you need to do is click the corresponding button to insert an automated table of contents. You can also do the same for your list of figures.

Everytime you need to make sure that these two tables are correct, just RIGHT-CLICK and choose UPDATE FIELD.

TABLE OF CONTENTS button through the REFERENCES tab



TABLE OF FIGURES button through the REFERENCES tab


It is important to know that these buttons will yield black results if you did not use automated captions for figures and if you did not use the STYLE system for your headings.

The STYLE button is located in the HOME tab. You can format each of the styles of headings here depending on the writing style that you are using, whether APA or Chicago, or MLA. The formatting however is manual. You will have to assign the format for each heading number in the system with the appropriate elements such as bodlface, italics, But after you've done this, simply clicking on the STYLE button and  and selecting the appropriate style will automatically do two things. 

  1. It will format the text based on the chosen style.
  2. It will refer to that text based on the chosen style.


STYLE button through the HOME tab


The standard style options in MS Word



Part of writing style is the used of headings. Those are the titles of the different sections and subsections of your manuscript. For example, "Chapter 1" can be considered as Heading 1. "Introduction" and "Statement of the Problem" can be considered as Heading 2 texts. Any other sub-sections under a Heading 2 can be Heading 3 as needed. For example, "Background of the Study" can be a Heading 2. If you have 3 topics for the background, then the titles for each will be Heading 3.

These the titles that you used for each headings will be recorded in your documents system. When you generate the automated table of contents, it will list these headings and their corresponding pages. These headings will also become part of the navigation pane. Pressing CTRL+F will open the navigation pane and display each heading. You can click each heading if you want to automatically teleport to that section of your manuscript. Headings also function as REFERENCE TYPE in cross-references.

If you convert your MS Word document into a PDF, these cross-references and automated elements can function as hyperlinks so that clicking them can automatically open the page that you need. The navigation pane will also appear in the PDF and will serve as a useful tool in reaching specific sections of the document.


So, I hope you can use these helpful tools. I wrote this blog also thinking that whoever reads this at least knows how to go about MS Word even if not knowing all the special powers of this software. Please comment if there's anything that needs clarification. Also remember, these tools are meant to help make life easy. Avoid sloppy work, use the tools. We still, however need to guide the intelligence of the software i.e. updating fields whenever you know you've made significant changes.























Thursday, December 26, 2024

Writing in Style

The stress of data gathering and navigating your way around the substance of your argument can sometimes impact your writing style, especially when you are not a writer. Here are essential things to remember when writing research, especially one's thesis or dissertation. This is also important when writing CVs and resumes. 

If it's a school thesis or class paper, make sure to format the manuscript according to the prescribed format. What's the paper size? In Taiwan, it's customary to use A4. In the Philippines, it's Letter size. How about the font style and size? When there's no prescribed font, my go-to is Palatino Linotype 11. Should the paragraphs be aligned left or justified? 

Those are basic, but it's important to know them because it's part of the institutional signature. Now for a bit of advanced style. What's the prescribed referencing and writing style? And by that, we mean APA, Chicago, MLA, and other schools of style. Those are not just for citations. If your university or class does not have prescriptions for headings and subheadings, captioning figures, and titles on tables, those have them. So, if your references follow APA 7th, they follow the same on your headings, subheadings, captions, and table titles. 

Let's get more professional. Mastering the data means you know how to report the data. You don't just write down your qualitative and quantitative results. There are styles for reporting evidentiary data in your results and discussion depending on the data type. More often, you follow the same school as the citation, for example, on how to report different statistical data and on how to report interview quotes. A deeper difference is on block texts.  You move away from the paragraph and start a block text if the quote is more than 40 words in APA; in Chicago, you do so if the quote is more than 100 words. Any quote with less remains within the regular paragraph text.

These make your manuscript acceptable for publication in a journal at first glance. Of course, what will finally get you final approval is the content. But you need to first do the secret handshake. This is the secret handshake. The editors and writers see style, and they recognize that someone who submitted is part of the club when they see the style of the manuscript.

Lastly, if you are writing a thesis or dissertation. These all go into the section on Notes on Style. If your university has no prescription and is flexible on the parts of the manuscript, you can also add it.

The Notes on Style reports the style that you followed.

I am doing this on my dissertation as a reminder for myself and as a shortcut for panel/committee members. This helps them to easily identify the style used and be in compliance with any prescribed styles.

Monday, November 13, 2023

Why are you doing this?

Metrobank Foundation recognized Teacher of the Year - Dr. Allan De Guzman has a principle that "when the why is clear, the how is easy." 

It's important to remember when navigating the academic wilderness, especially when you have already entered the writing phase - be it a term paper or your opus of a thesis or dissertation.

Papers for one. These come in many forms: term paper, weekly paper, weekly response, and issue paper. They are often used as major grading outputs. Hence, hitting the mark when writing something like this is crucial. Again - know why you are here, and as a corollary, why are you writing this.

Several students fail or get low grades on a paper simply because the professor has already laid out the goals for that writing assignment, and the student just writes anything on that topic. Sloppy.

For today, let's put the perspective of writing a thesis or a dissertation and go through some general points to answer the question Why are you doing this?


To graduate

You may not graduate if this is your only purpose. Of course, all students intend to graduate. But for now, we are at a phase of writing your great work/accomplishment, which serves as proof that you do merit (not I did not say deserve) to graduate. This is one of the reasons why a certain school task can be tedious, boring, irritating, or simply difficult to do. It;s because the student may have entered a perspective that divorces the task from the goal of graduation. The next two are better general perspectives.


To advocate

Particularly within the social sciences and humanities, advocacy is part of life. Something that we fight for. When you write to advocate, the data you produce can help push forward the advocacy. Take, for example, me; I advocate for the environment and for the welfare and rights of LGBT. 

An essential caution is that advocacy can be biased, preachy, or both. In addressing this, first, resolve if your paper is intended to be normative or scientific. Scientific papers require freedom from biases, though they can get preachy. 

Also, make sure you detail any steps you take in your methods to make your data as unbiased as possible. 

And, of course, tone down the preaching. Get off the high horse, get off the podium/pedestal, and talk to your reader instead of giving them a sermon.


To argue

Of course, we argue when we advocate. Still, I distinguish this from the previous section by pointing out that in this perspective, we argue because we are trying to establish newly discovered information or fact and prove its veracity.

For example, St. Thomas argued that there is a God. This saint also argued that theft is sometimes allowable. Charles Darwin argued that living beings evolved and were not created in the way the Bible says. Galileo and his peers also argued that the Earth revolves around the sun as opposed to the reverse argument.

Remembering that you are trying to prove undiscovered or unrecognized information will structure your thinking and research attitude to sequence, organize, and logically prove your argument. Instead of simply wanting to graduate, you may pick convenient methods and data that are not the right ones to fit the job.


Below is a simple quote from today's Magic: The Gathering card. Tune in next week when we further talk about perspectives in writing.





Sunday, October 29, 2023

Where to begin (writing a research proposal)

Elementary

Let's first familiarize ourselves with the components of IMRAD.

I - Introduction

M - Method

RAD - Results and Discussion

These are the basic components of publishable research. 

There are, of course, unmentioned parts.

It ends with a Conclusion, and the entire set is preceded by an Abstract.

The introduction contains it the following important elements:

  • The Hook, the opening part of the introduction, should catch the reader's attention and make them want to continue reading.
    • Strategies include a puzzling question, a quote, or a description of an interesting event.
  • Backgrounder - I use this wording instead of Background because not all submission formats use this as a heading. However, the content remains important. This informs the reader of information that they need to better understand what you are talking about
    • An excellent example is my own dissertation experience. My topic is very interdisciplinary. It includes media and social science because I'm studying Boys Love on TV. So, we can only expect the media experts to know a little of the social sciences part and vice versa. More so, expect that only some of your readers will fully know your topic. This section bridges that issue.
  • The problem statement group. I say group because there's a unique relationship among them. This group comprises the Literature review, Research question, and Framework.
For the sake of completeness, I'm mentioning that Methods can have its own subheadings depending on the complexity of the research. In particular, an Ethics Declaration should be declared if the research can touch on a sensitive subject of study.

Praxis

The above lists a sequential order of layout for publishable material. It does not mean that it was produced in the same sequence. Let's trace the actual process of how it is done.
  1. Gather and familiarize with literature.
    • I also collate the details of my pieces of literature onto an organized spreadsheet, but that's my personal strategy.
  2. Compose the framework and problem statement.
  3. Write the backgrounder.
  4. Write the Literature Review.
  5. Write your Method.
This sequence ensures that you have a certain degree of expertise within the field that you are studying. Part of this is your knowledge of the existing literature. Who are the currently published people who say something on the topic? Are their articles engaging each other? Complementing? Debating? Extending? 

A good illustration is attending a high-end gala. It would be weird if you did not know who the movers and shakers were in the event. 

It's the same thing with a proposal. How is it that you are proposing, yet you only have the basics? You need to know what's being discussed in the community.

If you have this, it proves in the proposal that you are ready to undertake your mission to prove your own thesis/dissertation (which is a synonym for argument).

As I say good luck to any of my readers, I also include this day's relevant Magic: the Gathering card. Just check out the quote (flavor text).





Friday, November 11, 2022

Jargon, Method, Design

Matches

It’s quite possble that we can have brilliant ideas but the panel of experts to whom we submit a proposal find the proposal unacceptable and gives us a ton of, “why not do this instead.”

This can mean that either you’re encountering “reviewer 2” (there’s a current FB group now who makes fun of the personas of “reviewer number 2.”)

Or

The way the proposal was constructed did not easily convey the brilliance that was being communicated.

Let’s get the easier one out of the way first: grammar and composition.

  • Make sure to have checked with Grammarly (even with the free one).
  • Maker sure to double check using MS Word Editor (even if you used a paid version of Grammarly).
  • Make sure to have someone else reread for you (you can make a mistake and not see it when you reread simply because you thought what you did was correct, so be humble and ask a friend to be critical and be thankful for critical comments).
  • Make sure to reread since it’s you who wrote it and restating certainb parts or not should be your decision.
Now for the more adavanced: Jargon.

Jargon is the secret handshake of the discipline where you hope to be accepted as either a bachelor of, a master of, or a doctor of.

Each discipline has their own way of wording and saying things (note “wording” as using terms, and “saying” as way of composing sentences and even paragraphs). Each discipline also has their own writing style i.e. APA, MLA, Chicago (those are not just for citations).

Research also has its own nuances when it comes to communication.

There’s the design of the research (which is technical, like case study, phenomenology, hypothesis testing, descriiptive profiling) and the design of the manuscript (the organization of the manuscript content, which can be a bit creative but yet should be tempered logically).

Oftentimes, these should mix like a nicely chosen set of clothes in order to work well.

Take for example, using the phrase “to prove” is usually quantitative jargon specially if you are trying to etablish that your independent variable does affect the dependent variable.

This does not mean that qualitative does not prove. So, you also have to dig deep on what you are trying to prove.

Measure is also a word that tends to be quite quantitative. It’s going to be weird if you are describing the impact (i.e. Fragmented, unified, facilitated, corrected) and then you use the word measure when you are not even measuring (high, low). Again, what are you using the evidence for?

We talked about “beginning at the end” last week, and it’s a good thought also for today.

What are you trying to do?

So, make sure that your jargon, your method, and your design matches with what your envisioned purpose of the research is.

A larger purpose

Speaking of purpose, there's another end which should be considered when you think of why you are writing. Each of the three ranks of higher education produce an magnum opus (Trans. from Latin = Great Work," opus for short).

  • Bachelors (undergrads) and the Masters (1st rank of postgrad) both produce their own thesis.
  • Doctors (PhDs) write a dissertation. 
Here's a trivia. Universities are defined as a community of scholars. Individuals who produce knowledge.

The Bachelors produce knowledge by testing existing theories (I will consider that as a minimum, if you can produce the ones in the next rank, why not). 

Doctors produce knowledge by formulating theories and even laws within the discipline (I.e. Huntington's Theory on the Clash of Civilizations, Michel's Iron Law of Oligarchy).

Masters are in between, they can either test theory or create one.

How does this factor in on your research?

Knowing that you are either producing or testing theory helps you develop your review of literatures.

  • It helps you in how to treat your theoretical framework and conceptual framework.
  • It helps you in finding out what evidence (data) you need,
  • It helps you determine what method and design to use in gathering and analyzing the evidence.
  • It helps you know what jargon to use.
  • It gives you a bigger purpose. Don't write for submission, write because you have something to say (as what I've said in Principles of Writing, and in the first post last October).

Just look at this link for inspiring examples so that you can have a perspective on why in the nine hells are you taking your degree. This is not to pressure, it's to inspire.

Also check out our MTG card for today below. It's Minamo School of Wizards, the Japanese MTG version of Hogwarts, nicely situated above a waterfall. Check out the quote in the card.

Photo credit to Wizards of the Coast, Inc.,    https://gatherer.wizards.com/Handlers/Image.ashx?multiverseid=79179&type=card

Wednesday, November 02, 2022

Begin at the End

There was a nice discussion on differences on dependent variable treatment yesterday in Dr. Nachman's class where we talked about choosing dependent variables.

You see, dependent variables are the end half of an argument's equation.

Independent Variable (IV)  -> Dependent Variable (DV)


The IV impacts on the DV,

      or the IV causes the DV... etc...


In quantitative research, you don't select sample cases based on the dependent variable for the reason that quantification usually means you are trying to prove the relationship that the IV caused or has an effect on the DV.

But in qualitative, you can sometimes make the sample choices based on the DV because you are not proving that the ID did impact on the DV but rather what you are trying to discover is on how.


But that's not why we are here today, I simply used that to introduce our topic. Begin with the end in mind (which in a way related to making choices based on DVs 😀 ).


What we've been focusing on in the past few weeks are things that help us write or help us begin to write, or even the ingredients that we can use as we do so.


For today we have these important life-research lessons, akin to my predilections on being practical and economic in any action that I do.


Esteemed educator and researcher Dr. Allan De Guzman speaks of the tenet - "When the why is clear, the how is easy."


So, keep that in mind as you begin to even think of writing. What's your end goal?


Let's further translate that here into practical samples.


Why write if the only goal is submit in class? There's a weirdness to this. Professors usually have "publishable" as the top quality for the highest scores for class papers.


Here's a scenario, we usually have insight or good manner of expressing ourselves or both. These things get us recognition on the potential of our work. But, are they journal ready?


That's our goal for today because it's sad that sometimes it's such an effort to revise after submission that papers with good potential already get pushed on the side and seldom get submitted,


Here are important strategies to note.


  • What discipline or sub-discipline are you writing for? This will impact on several things that may need to be redone if you did not have this in mind.
  • If you know the discipline, then you will know two things (or find out). 1. What journals do publish such material as you have in mind to write. 2. What's the writing style?
  • Most disciplines have their own style. For example, most political science researches use APA, but political theory use Chicago (and usually footnote rather than parenthetical in-text citations).
  • There's also another factor, sometimes the journal itself has a preferred citation style, so after you determine the discipline, look for your target journal.
  • But how about if you get rejected and need to shift journals and the new journal has a different preferred style? That's where citation tools are useful. I checked with a prominent journal and even they say that people should not be doing manual method of writing bibliographies/references anymore. This is because if you need to shift, then all you will need to do is change the format of the tool and the entire list of references (along with the in-text) will be updated. Remember our last magic card, use the tools!
  • TAKE NOTE THOUGH! I used the wording "writing style" awhile back on bullet 2. APA, Chicago, MLA... those are not just citation formats. They are Manuals of Style. The way they organize written text contain unique nuances that say "hey, this is written for this particular academic community who happen to speak the same academic language." So, the heading style, outline numbering, and even captioning may be different. Not all of these cannot be automated, though there are tutorials on YouTube on how to automate (I wouldn't say they're complete though). The rule here is know the style and adjust as necessary. 
  • Another element of writing style is what mode of English do they use? American or British? So, best to begin with this in mid too.
  • More often than not, the "sciences" use third person in writing. But there are particular subdisciplines in political science which doesn't do so. Again, if you know the journal, then you're better off.
Those are but a few, but they can help save you a big chunk of time and even help you publish.

Don't let your ideas go to waste as simply submissions that end up only in your hard drive.

Check out the systematic system on how goblins use artillery in today's MTG card (I don't agree in using people as cannon fodder though, just be systematic please).

Image copyrighted to Wizards of the Coast: https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=45467


Thursday, October 27, 2022

Arguments and Variables

 Let’s the the basics of the building blocks of an argument - varaibles.

We always talk about this when reading, analyzing, or doing research, but what are they?

One way to see them are as subjects and predicates of a sentence.

If you’ve undertook logic classs before, it’s also similar.

I.e. Something is ______.

The most basic format of a statement. Mind you not all statements are argumentative statements.

Basically, there’s at least three in political science.

  1. Sample - you argue, women should not expect men to treat them like delicate flowers (Wollstonecrafts argument). This is a normative argument, it’s not testable, but it’s arguable. Your purpose here is to give support for you argument on why a certain gender (women) should act based on a particular norm (being treated delicately).
  2. Sample - you argue, more women in government reduces corruption. This is a positive statement, it’s arguable, and can be tested (you can check a number of governments and see if they do). What you are doing here is try tp prove that governments with more elected women officials really do reduce corruption. Notice a difference, normative arguments say how things should be, while positive arguments try to describe the world.
  3. Sample - you argue, Philippine civil society is on a decline. This is an evaluative or assessment argument. You’re making judgement on something based on a particular set criteria.
Variables are the components of the argument that have “variations.”

Let’s see,
  1. In the first sample, if we simply look at the specificity of the argument, there might not seem any variation. But when we look at the classes over which the two parts belong, women is a variation of gender. Expectation of treatment is another and is a variation of s norm. You can also frame your variable in terms of what kind of women should abide by this proposed argument? Strong women? Though that can cause a different for of debate. But rermember, the quality is arguable, then expect a debate on the topic.
  2. The second example is where Independent and Dependent Variables are usually used. The idea of dependence and independence ais a relationship etween them. The Independent variable usually has an impact on the dependent. Hence, in the example, Corruption is a variable, it’s the dependent. It’s affected by the kind of gender that officials have (or even the number of a kind of gender, multiple variations). Gender here is the independent variable. So what’s the variations for corruption? In the case of this argument, it’s degree, so we’re talking about a potential quantitative study. The same for woemen, the variation ca be the high or low number of women officials.
  3. In the third sample, there was only one variable, and we’retrying to see the variation in terms of the Philippine’s civil society. Sometimes you can just do it this way, but may seem incomplete. You can instead evaluate the civil society’s effectiveness in advocating for human rights. So here you already know what category it’s being evaluated.  You can check variations of civic activity (i.e. Rallies, social media engagement, membership), it’s your independent variable. How did we know t’s independent though? Check out the operational connector between them - “effectiveness” so who (IV) afects who (DV). Another variation that you ca research here is the degree of effectiveness.
These are the basic building blocks of an argument. So check it out for yourself, think of current issues, identify variables and their potential units of variation. Are the units numeric? Then your research will be quantitative. Are the units words and ideas? Then your research will be qualitative.

It’s part of the science, you don’t choose the method because you like or don’t like math. You choose it because it matches your argument. Then you recruit a statistician or a data analyst if you have a particular weakness on the method.

This links us back to niche. As I mentioned last time, your niche is your expertise or even your passion or concern. And this can be either your dependent or independent variables.  I.e. Gender, corruption, environment, pollution, etc. Or your expertise can be on a particular method.

This coincides with flavor text for our Magic: The Gathering card for today, check it out below.




Wednesday, October 19, 2022

Your Niche

I was thinking whether or not to write on this topic since it can cause problems if mishandled. But it's still an important element of why we write so, let's disentangle the puzzle.

The "niche" or research niche is your academic expertise. The problem is, not everyone has a clear cut vision on where they want to go. Some students are not even sure of their own course, or some family reason is why they're not in the course that they want. I won't answer those directly but rather with this discourse: 

  • It's always better to have a plan. Education is expensive, best to maximize the years spent on your course. 
  • BUT
  • If you don't have a plan yet, BE STILL, get a moment where you can talk to yourself and find out your plan.
  • BUT
  • If your "self" is being silent, or you don't have a moment to BE STILL, then ask yourself for now, what is your take away from where you are now? I.e. your course/program.
  • BUT
  • If you're not having any takeaway, there's something terribly wrong going on. You have to address this.
  • BUT
  • If you can't address it, then just have fun. This is the counterpoise that not everyone has a plan yet. Don't stress yourself out, and don't overburden yourself with drama queen stuff like "I'm just trying to get through." Laugh at the ridiculousness of the situation and find something fun to do while dealing with the reality of "getting through."
- - - 

Let's now focus on the practicality of a niche, maybe this can help guide you find yours (if you don't know yet), or help you plan along yours (if you already have).

Your thesis whether college, master's or PhD (dissertation) is the crowning glory of that level's academic life. That's the reason why I have a bias against courses that don't do a thesis. Take note, even students at the Conservatory of Music may not have a "thesis" per se but they have a recital, which is just the same - the test and outcome which proves that you have mastered that level.

We have to go through a tour of an institution in Robert Jordan's The Wheel of Time novels in order to do this (no worries, no spoilers).

This institution is the White Tower, headquarters of the Aes Sedai (trans. from the Old Tongue = Servants of All). The Aes Sedai are humans gifted with the power to channel power, but what's most important is aside from the fictional supernatural power that they train to use, they also specialize in two other powers: knowledge and politics (that's why the prequel, New Spring is usually first reading for political science freshmen when I used to teach Political Science as a Profession). At present in the timeline of the books, Aes Sedai were all women (I won't go into the details), and in order to attain the rank of "Aes Sedai, a girl enters the White Tower and becomes a Novice. Novices are expected to attend their classes, follow the prescribed lessons, follow instructions, and not to question their teachers (I kind of disagree with the last one). After years of training and a difficult test, the novice is promoted to the rank of Accepted. The Accepted gain a certain degree of freedom, they get to choose what they want to study, choose their time for lessons with specific teachers, and are expected to question things. Again, grueling years of training and a test (the political science freshmen usually encounter this in New Spring) called the Hundred Weaves, then woman is raised to Aes Sedai, and one Aes Sedai (Cadsuane Melaidhrin, Aes Sedai of the Green Ajah) comments while reminiscing her years after her "graduation" that that is the point when one truly learns.

There was a huge fan run website called WoTmania and it contained a rich collection of fan activity. Seriously, RICH. There was a section on theories where site registered members can post well thought of theories, and you will suspect that the people posting are either college or post-college level students.

I found an article there that likened the 3 ranks as college, master's and PhD's (sadly WoTmania has been closed after the devastation of Jordan's death). Another argued that the three ranks are elementary, high school, and college.


So, you have x years before writing your research, usually it's on your second or third year. 

  • IF you treat your brains like a temporary computer memory rather than a hard drive, then we have a problem, because where's the mastery?

  • IF you are not taking something away for your future plans, then we have a problem (I say we because sometimes, it's not the student but something else which is the cause, yes TEA 😎 ).

  • IF you get nothing in each course that's useful to your future writing, then again, problem.

So, keep in heart the lessons, the readings, and all discussions, because you will need them.

It's from here where you might be able to find your niche.  Attend to your lessons.

Another is, like the Accepted, find an expert and learn from them. It's like an apprenticeship. Being a Research Assistant (RA) or Teaching/Teacher's Assistant (TA) is an example.

And always remember what Cadsuane Sedai said, after graduation is when you truly learn. Hence, after High School graduation, you are a student in college, open your mind and use the previous lessons, don't make them hindrance to fill in your brain. If the muscles of the body get toned by working out, then do the brain workouts.

Let's end today with the quote from the card below. A quote with so many layers. An Adept is someone who has attained expertise (PhD) in a field (a niche). There is often a temptation that makes people arrogant, avoid that temptation. In the quote, don't follow the idea of taking something that is not yours though, let it be a proscription (not to do). Never plagiarize, get your takeaway from the lessons, "the things that will be yours" when you write your own ideas. And make your own ideas, propose them and support them with evidence. That's the essence of an original thesis.

Image from Wizards of The Coast, Inc., https://gatherer.wizards.com/Handlers/Image.ashx?multiverseid=4729&type=card









Wednesday, October 12, 2022

The Elementary Chicken and Egg Question

It's day 2 of the cold period of Autumn here now and it's difficult to get out from wanting to stay in bed and just enjoy the cold while under a warm comforter.  So, I'll do my brain warm-up with this blogpost before proceeding to do my writing tasks today.

***

There was a style during the dinosaur era of thesis writing when the main problem in the Statement of The Problem and the Title of the thesis reflect each other syntactically, that is, the former is in a statement which is like a question made into a declarative sentence of what ought to be answered while the latter is either a description of how you have answered such question or a teaser the answer itself..

Let's have samples

Statement of the Problem: This research seeks to answer how federalism is applicable to the Republic of the Philippines.  (Note that the question is embedded in the declarative sentence.)

Title: Federalism and Its Potential Application to the Republic of the Philippines (teaser answer, a bit more modern than the time of the dinosaurs)

Title: An Comparative Constitutional Analysis on the Potential Application of Federalism on the Republic of the Philippines (tells how you answered the question).

Note: These samples are in my successfully defended Master's thesis.  Just Google Castillo Philippines Federalism (yes, flex that I'm googleable 😅 )

Now from this exercise, what we can notice are important elements of what makes an argument.

Concept Note: Sometimes we forget the breadth and depth of the terms that we use. My esteemed professor on the Philosophy of Man, Dr. Florentino Hornedo, reminded our class on what element is: something that constitutes another thing, or the basic building blocks of a thing.  Without them the thing is either incomplete or it is already something different.

So, we have:

  • problems/puzzles
  • arguments/theses 
  • and the how you bridged them or how you answered them - your methodology
The question on what goes first among the three is a triadic version of the chicken and egg version, and my answer is "it depends." What we're here for today is how do we begin, in this case for each.

Let's begin with the unique one (therefore less likely, and in a way, more advanced, plus easier to describe for this blog).

When you use method as part of a title, even modern titles still do it (but you will see points of difference from the true dinosaurs) it's the part of the method uses is usually the design.  I.e. case study, regression analysis, fuzzy models, ethnography, etc. There are unique researchers who's research niches are not on specific topics, i.e. public policy, leviathans, IR, American politics, clientelist politics, environment, etc., but rather on the method. They have a mastery of a specific design and they usually or always use it. 

There's an important takeaway from there, familiarity. It;s a person's familiarity with the method which makes it a good first step for each research undertaking.

Let's look into disciplinary topics rather than methods: puzzles and arguments.

I once said in the "Principles of Writing" previously posted on this blog that you write  because you have something to say - an argument.

But what makes a valid argument?

This is can be tempered by the puzzle that you are tinkering on.

One thing that can block us is that we don't have a clear puzzle because we are unfamiliar with the world of our discipline.

So, check yourself:

  • Have you conversed with both the classic and the contemporary masters? (the writers who were the classic references on the topic, and the most recent celebrities being talked about on that particular topic) i.e. if you're doing Federalism, have you read the Federalist Papers, Elazar for classic and international sources? Have you read Pimentel, Abueva, and Tayao among the contemporary Philippine sources? This tells you the state of the discussion. Imagine, there's this debate and you butt in with a statement which has already been said. The shame.  So what's new with yours?  What do you bring into the debate?  Is there something unanswered in the debate?
  • Have you been out and about or have you simply been going to school-home-gimmick/hangouts cycle and no other exposure? I.e. do you go out for community engagement? Have you been to congress? Have you attended a rally?  You don't need all of these but have you participated in on what you plan to write on? Sometimes we have no problem because things are tyoo abstract for us.
  • Have you been reading the news? This is a twin to the previous one.  It helps you look into what's going on in the world.
  • Are you familiar with history? 
Check out the flavor quote on this card in my favorite card game.

Image from Wizards of the Coast, Inc.

Don't just do one.

The other thing that can block us in arguing is the degree of our familiarity with our discipline.

So, let's look at elemental components of the discipline as a study, since arguments become knowledge within the field (it's science).

Look at these arguments:

  • Justice should be fairness (Rawls).
  • What makes a strong state is the formation of elite pacts in response to the critical juncture of contentious politics (from Slater's "Ordering Power").
  • Policy salience causes a thermostatic response on voter behavior (Chris Wlezein).

The first one is a normative argument. It proposes a mode of behavior,  This is done through politically theorizing on the concepts of justice and fairness. It doesn't mean that it is done without field work or any systematic method.  There's a qualitative method for these.

The second one is an empirical qualitative argument describing the foundation of state power. It described historical events on the formation of states.

The third one is an empirical quantitative argument. It can statistically test if policy salience does makes voters change their vote from one election and the next election.

There are many other possible variations. But, what can we take away from that exercise? Here are some key points?

  • Is your argument too specific such that only people in your barangay, town, or country might be interested?  I.e. "Duterte is a an efficient chief executive." Is too specific as a study and better as a news opinion page article. But if you make a study on what makes chief executives inefficient, then you are on to something.
  • Is your argument debatable? To say that "All chief executives should prioritize public service." Is a generalizable statement but it's undebatable (since it's already acceptable).  But if you can make can propose, x,y, and z constitute the qualities of a good leader, then it's more debatable since I can argue a different set or I can propose an addition to your list. 
  • Is your argument testable? The previous example is also untestable, it is something that says something should be done.  The counterposed one that I gave is testable, let's see, let's go to this leader who is supposed to be a good leader, do they have such qualities? Wow, the list is incomplete.  Ok, new paper.
  • Is your argument positive? It should say what something is rather than what it is not.  I.e. "The Philippine government is not a true democracy." Ok, so what is it?  
Ok, that's it for now.  Up next week is a short one on niches and publishing, to be followed by thinking of variables.





Wednesday, October 05, 2022

All that talk on theory and where do we begin writing...

I haven't posted since I left Manila almost a year ago.  It will actually be 1 year in 5 days from today.  I guess the auspice of today being International Teacher's Day is a good start to share things.  Some quick blog nuances.  You might notice a pattern on the authorship of each blogpost as you go down the archives.  Sometimes it's my moniker in Spart - Empress - and sometimes it's the more formal full name with the official pre/suffixes.  The blog was born from my old personal email, which got associated to the moniker. I've added the formal email for the sake of the accreditations that Sparta encounters, a bit of homage to our honored guests.

But for the time being, I'll be using the one with the moniker since I'm writing as a faculty on leave and currently studying here in Taiwan. 

With that, let's go to the heart of today's post.


I've been pondering on the puzzle of my own upcoming dissertation writing life, and thus my research questions.  This part is a constant reminder to me by my adviser, Natalie (Wong, one of the coolest and insightful professors ever, don't ever call her by full name nor address her with 'professor' that's how she jams).  Part and parcel of having a topic is having a set of research questions. 

The answer to your research question is your thesis, the word thesis being synonymous to argument.

Not addressing this ends up with the usual, we have a topic but no argument.

Note: as a way of illustrating I'd sometimes refer to my topic, but since I don;t like broadcasting ideas until it gets published, we will affectionately call it WITNHIT (short for what in the nine hells is that!?)

Going back, so we have questions and the argument we pose to address that question.

There's another cool prof that I have this semester, Dr. Lev Nachman. One of the cool parts is that he graduated from UCI, so I can imagine myself as being mentored by a professor from the mythical CalSci (hi Daniella and Lolit :) ) in the Numb3rs TV series :D.

But he's got a really nice engaging way of class discussions.  During these he calls the question or what is generally called "problem" as PUZZLE/S.

Let use that for our own mindwalk. 


As political or social students, let's imagine ourselves at a place, our potential study site?

Imagine the phenomenon, the event we're interested with, i.e. an election, a protest, a something happening at a market place, an accident, a disaster, or a fan meet?

Is there anything puzzling?

Here's where one of my favorite quotes in magic the gathering comes in :D


Yes look and observe, see the building blocks: who, what, when, where.

Then check the higher order parts: why and how?

There was a great war in the the early and mid 1900's, who were involved? what was done? 

But why? and how?

Now let's take it a bit further.  Is this how and/or why causal?

It's from this where you can proceed even toward your methodology - is there a systematic way on how I can prove this how/why?

But we're not here today for method, we're here on the germ from which we begin research.

And we have puzzles, theses, and also a third one: theory.

You could've began thinking of your topic because you saw a puzzle (question/problem).

You could've began thinking of a topic because you have an argument (we'll do a separate one on the ramifications of this next week).

And you could also begin with theory.

How best do we use theory?

A theory is already an existing argument in the body  of literature.

I.e. Weber's, Tilly's, Castillo's (ehem, just kidding on the third).

One way is...


Since a theory exists, then if there's already a detailed set of variables on that theory, you can test it.  This is conducted quantitatively.

This reminds us also of systematic thinking.  You can't just choose quanti over quali because math is your weakness or you like math over reading long interviews.

Just like any part of a thesis, can you defend it? I.e. this study quantitative because the author is testing X's theoty, which was originally used in North America, and we are now testing it's universality by testing it across the Pacific, in Southeast Asia.

Another way is 

You are either challenging the theory or expanding on the theory by qualitatively looking at possible variations of the original variables.  I.e. An argument says that state failure (dependent variable) is caused by the loss of monopoly of the use of force (independent variable).  Is it possible that there may be other causes other than the loss of this state capacity?  Notice now that I classified "monopoly of the use of force" under "state capacity." (this is where your excellent grasp of concepts and jargons after more than two years in the discipline comes in).  

Since one concept can belong under the umbrella of another, and there's possibility of other concepts within that same umbrella, then a possible pathway for the analytic methodology is classification.  I.e. this paper intends to classify variations of causes of state failure in the Middle East.

Or, you might instead map out the process on how "capacity to monopolize use of force" is lost.  In this case you are discovering processes rather than categories. 

A variation of this way is

You have an alternative theory to clash with the first theory or your possible findings will create a new theory.


Before we close for this post, a reminder.

One reason why you have tons of readings is that it gives you insights on the vast body of literatures that there are within the discipline.  This in a way is your preparation which leads you either to a puzzle, an argument, or a counter theory for your own writing.

Another is field exposure, that is why going out of the four corners of the classroom is important.

Field trips are not often but...

Every time you read the news, you are going out to the field (note that reputable news, magazines, and books are literatures too.

Every time you go out to engage with communities, i.e. community development activities.

So go out and about.  Observe, take notes in your mind or jot them down in a JOURNAL of your own, like some field researching Indian Jones.

And think of readings a puzzles that you are unlocking:

Let's end with another cool prof.  Dr. Courtney Work, my powerful professor of ethnology who gives us ACE-FA

That's the:

Argument

Conversation (how did the author talk to other authors - that's his/her/their review of literature, so that you know how to do yours)

Evidences (how did the paper prove the argument? what evidences?)

Those three are at the heart of the readings.

FA are for checking out quality (for when you are the one picking up references)

Funding - so you know if the author is biased or has real clout.

Author - let's you know of the reputability of the article (also check out the quality of the journal, more on this in future posts)

That's it for now.

Happy International Teacher's Day to me, my mentors, and my colleagues.