Good morning!
Announce to each block.
Sem 2 Individual final output will be a one page essay
To be graded based on:
Clarity 5 pts
- clear direct statements.
Coherence 5 pts
- each sentence’s idea flows from one to the next, creating 1 full paragraph.
Reasoning 5 pts
- all paragraphs state, and is able to prove a point.
Evidence 5 pts
- what you claim is based on the seminar, cited based on presence in the seminar or based on the video.
Picture 5 pts
- There should be two pictures. One that shows your presence in a seminar, and another that shows your accomplishment/task in the seminar. Pictures is suggested to be 2 x 3 or 3 x 2. Make sure it is clear and laid out properly on the page.
Total of 25 pts. Everyone begins with a merit of 5 in each category. One demerit per error or non compliance.
Everything should fit in 1 long bond paper.
Lay out as best as you could. Balance content w creativity.
Documentation team will compile per block. Alphabetical in a clear book.
Clear book must have a decent and creative cover. Stating:
Seminar 2
Batch
Professor (incomplete this part and the clear book is discarded)
Seminar title, venue, date
2nd page: the program
3rd page the committees
Essay content!
Every paragraph is only 5 sentences.
1st - the experience of working the seminar.
2nd - insight from the seminar. By definition in Pol 201 (your very 1st major) insight is deep understanding. Don’t give me something at face value.
3rd - what can you recommend based on the issue?
4th - how can that recommendation be accomplished?
Remember, I’m giving you 1 paragraph each, 5 sentence chance each. With clear, direct sentence requirement.
Be sure to impress me w one shot.
Submission is 3pm on Saturday, May 4, 2019.
Your Pol Sci journey has already culminated.
Show to me your worth. Brilliant, clear, balanced. (St. Thomas’ Philosophy of what is beautiful.)
Temet nosce (Greek: know yourself).
Valar morghulis (Valyrian: do your best).
Zhai helleva (Tayledras: wind to thy wings).
Online classroom of Ronald Castillo y Maglaqui, Professor of Political Science at the University of Santo Tomas - Faculty of Arts and Letters. But for the time being, starting 2022, this blog serves as a student's public notebook of thoughts while he undertakes his international PhD in Asia Pacific Studies at National Chengchi University, Taipei, Taiwan. Reach him through rmcastillo@ust.edu.ph
Saturday, April 27, 2019
Tuesday, April 09, 2019
Research Inspiration: sample of descriptive research (applied sciences)
The Emperor of Japan is a researcher!
What’s his thesis?
The gobies in the pond are hybrid species.
The gobies interbreed in the wild.
What’s his thesis?
The gobies in the pond are hybrid species.
The gobies interbreed in the wild.
Check out his study.
Sunday, April 07, 2019
The Thesis Defense
The essence of the defense is
1. It simulates the presentation of a truth that you discovered.
2. It proves to the panel that it was you who wrote your thesis.
1. It simulates the presentation of a truth that you discovered.
2. It proves to the panel that it was you who wrote your thesis.
The Defense PPT Parts
Preferably 1 slide each
Background of the Study
Statement of the Problem
Objectives of the Study
Significance of the Study
Scope and Limitations (if your topic is controversial)
Summary list of RRL themes w sample/best author,date source
Methodology
Findings/Presentation of Data :
simulacrum/diagram
Evidences of claims (mga ideas sa diagram) e.g. Quotes, pictures
Conclusion: sagutin ang statement of the problem
Recommendations
Defense PPT style
No or less animations. If you use animation, it should contribute SMOOTHLY to the presentation.
Apply Zen style: there should be ample blank spaces.
Use rule of seven: 7 lines of text per slide, 7 words per line.
Use bullets or numbered list to summarize chapters.
Use paragraphs only to tell a story, or a principle.
Use pictures or diagrams or graphs instead of text when possible. Since you’re supposed to be speaking.
The Delivery
Arrive / begin w a smile. Show a positive attitude. Negative facade can influence the panel.
Present it don’t report it.
If your goal is to present, you can deliver if told to do so within 5 minutes, or within 30 min. Because you “know” what you talking about, and what you need to deliver.
You can’t present if you do not know the thesis by heart.
The Defense
Answer clearly.
Leave pride at home.
Take in mind, you are presenting a proposal of a new idea. You can only be proud once you present it clear, logically, and the panel agrees. So be congenial, be clear, give proofs. If they don’t accept, they will question or shout at you, IT’S THEIR PRIVILEGE. Because they are the gatekeepers of the discipline. They hold MAs and PhDs, YOU are asking them to give you your bachelor’s degree. If you do ‘t believe me, go check the cover page of a thesis. It says: “in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of...”
Never argue with your panel. Explain to them.
Answer as clear and concise as possible. Provide details to prove your claim.
Your panel will see if: parangag hiuhugot mo lang ang sagot. The panel will also see if you bluff.
Thursday, March 28, 2019
ASN 902 For the Month of April: 4ASN3
Task is to meet as groups and plan a presentation on one the following topics. The next few weeks will be your research period in order to accomplish the 3 outcomes below. As such we won't be having regular meetings, and we meet again as class by April 26, 2019.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Topics/Readings
From Sigona et.al. Diasporas Reimagined
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
The Indigent Moslems Burial Fund By Nazneen Ahmed 96
The stateless speak back: Palestinian narratives of home(land) By Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh 194
The Jewish diaspora and Israel: problems of a relationship since the
Gaza wars By William Safran 202
Weapons of Knowledge Construction: the Afghan-American diaspora and counterinsurgency in Afghanistan
By Morwani Zafar 217
Presentation Grading
The following marks will be given for accomplishing each requirement of the task.
A. Each topic may touch on the one or more of the following migration concepts: Space (temporal and locational), Identity, Community, Homeland, Transference, Networks, Tropes. Make sure that you explain which one was illustrated by the article. 4 pts ___
B. Each topic to be presented by a group (composed of 7-8 members). Groups can accommodate 1 additional member once all groups have been filled-up. 2 pts (deduction of 6 pts for not following this) ___
C, Each group should outline properly their topic, presented in the powerpoint. 4 pts ___
D. Each group get 30 minutes to present. No reading. Be able to cross reference the concepts/theories that each article may have. 6 pts ___
E. Use powerpoint that follows the Zen style.
The Zen Style
- there should be ample empty space in each slide, hence not crowded. 2 pts
- use the Rule of 7. Each slide should have only 7 lines each. A line of text should have approximately 7 words. 2 pts ___
- use pictures. 2 pts ___
- use media that can enrich the Main Topic discussion. One media for the entire group. Again use rule of 7 for the media length. 6 pts ___
F, For each group: One member should submit at the comments box the list of members and their group topic by April 2, 2016. 4 pts ___
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
40 pts in total
ASN 902 For the Month of April: 4ASN2
Task is to meet as groups and plan a presentation on one the following topics. The next few weeks will be your research period in order to accomplish the 3 outcomes below. As such we won't be having regular meetings, and we meet again as class by April 26, 2019.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Topics/Readings
From Sigona et.al. Diasporas Reimagined
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
The Indigent Moslems Burial Fund By Nazneen Ahmed 96
The stateless speak back: Palestinian narratives of home(land) By Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh 194
The Jewish diaspora and Israel: problems of a relationship since the
Gaza wars By William Safran 202
Weapons of Knowledge Construction: the Afghan-American diaspora and counterinsurgency in Afghanistan
By Morwani Zafar 217
Presentation Grading
The following marks will be given for accomplishing each requirement of the task.
A. Each topic may touch on the one or more of the following migration concepts: Space (temporal and locational), Identity, Community, Homeland, Transference, Networks, Tropes. Make sure that you explain which one was illustrated by the article. 4 pts ___
B. Each topic to be presented by a group (composed of 7-8 members). Groups can accommodate 1 additional member once all groups have been filled-up. 2 pts (deduction of 6 pts for not following this) ___
C, Each group should outline properly their topic, presented in the powerpoint. 4 pts ___
D. Each group get 30 minutes to present. No reading. Be able to cross reference the concepts/theories that each article may have. 6 pts ___
E. Use powerpoint that follows the Zen style.
The Zen Style
- there should be ample empty space in each slide, hence not crowded. 2 pts
- use the Rule of 7. Each slide should have only 7 lines each. A line of text should have approximately 7 words. 2 pts ___
- use pictures. 2 pts ___
- use media that can enrich the Main Topic discussion. One media for the entire group. Again use rule of 7 for the media length. 6 pts ___
F, For each group: One member should submit at the comments box the list of members and their group topic by April 2, 2016. 4 pts ___
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
40 pts in total
ASN 902 For the Month of April: 4ASN1
Task is to meet as groups and plan a presentation on one the following topics. The next few weeks will be your research period in order to accomplish the 3 outcomes below. As such we won't be having regular meetings, and we meet again as class by April 26, 2019.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Outcomes:
1) Finalize your Newsletter, submission is April 27, 2019.
2) Plan a group presentation on a chosen topic from the list below, it will be presented on April 26 and 27, 2019. Al groups should be ready by then, and groups will be picked randomly.
3) Everyone is expected to read all the readings as listed below. Don't worry, they're not as toxic as some readings, they will constitute a quiz which will be administered on May 3, 2019.
For the presentation. Form groups of 7 - 8 members. Make sure to fill up to 7 members before proceeding to accumulate to 8. Based on the current population, there should be very few groups (probably 1 per block) that reach 8 members.
Topics/Readings
From Sigona et.al. Diasporas Reimagined
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
Making a Kurdistani identity in diaspora: Kurdish migrants in Sweden By Barzoo Eliassi 45
Associational profusion and multiple belonging: diaspora Nepalis in the UK By David N. Gellner 78
The Indigent Moslems Burial Fund By Nazneen Ahmed 96
The stateless speak back: Palestinian narratives of home(land) By Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh 194
The Jewish diaspora and Israel: problems of a relationship since the
Gaza wars By William Safran 202
Weapons of Knowledge Construction: the Afghan-American diaspora and counterinsurgency in Afghanistan
By Morwani Zafar 217
Presentation Grading
The following marks will be given for accomplishing each requirement of the task.
A. Each topic may touch on the one or more of the following migration concepts: Space (temporal and locational), Identity, Community, Homeland, Transference, Networks, Tropes. Make sure that you explain which one was illustrated by the article. 4 pts ___
B. Each topic to be presented by a group (composed of 7-8 members). Groups can accommodate 1 additional member once all groups have been filled-up. 2 pts (deduction of 6 pts for not following this) ___
C, Each group should outline properly their topic, presented in the powerpoint. 4 pts ___
D. Each group get 30 minutes to present. No reading. Be able to cross reference the concepts/theories that each article may have. 6 pts ___
E. Use powerpoint that follows the Zen style.
The Zen Style
- there should be ample empty space in each slide, hence not crowded. 2 pts
- use the Rule of 7. Each slide should have only 7 lines each. A line of text should have approximately 7 words. 2 pts ___
- use pictures. 2 pts ___
- use media that can enrich the Main Topic discussion. One media for the entire group. Again use rule of 7 for the media length. 6 pts ___
F, For each group: One member should submit at the comments box the list of members and their group topic by April 2, 2016. 4 pts ___
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
G. Each individual member will be graded on clarity of delivery 5 pts ___ And on mastery of topic 5 pts ____
40 pts in total
Wednesday, March 20, 2019
Writing Chapter V:
Chapter V Concludes the argument,
but not the manuscript.
It contains the Summary,
Conclusion, and Recommendations.
Summary
This presents a short narrative
from chapter I to Chapter IV. There
should be a range from 6 to 10 very short paragraphs for this. 1 to 2 paragraphs detailing each
chapter. When you write, you do not
refer to the chapter number, but rather, narrate the journey of your thesis. Tell how it came about, what the problem was,
the objective and significance. Of
course in a summarized manner (1 paragraph may be enough). This is followed by information on chapter 2. This will be 1 to 2 paragraphs. Highlight the themes and the significant
authors and their findings. At the end,
mention how your thesis fills the gap of information in the progress of the
literature on the topic. After which
will be a very short narration of what you did to gather data. Sample would be… “The researchers visited
city N to interview x number of residents.
This was for the pupose of describing the case of institutionalization
of gay marriage…” This part will range
from 1 to 2 paragraphs depending on how many methods of data gathering used
(e.g. some have interviews with 2 sets of people, some have 1 set of interview,
and 1 set of fgd). Last set of pragraphs
summarizes chapter 4. Simply gloss over
what you have found. What diagrams or
tables are worth mentioning.
Conclusion
The conclusion should be 2 (at
the very most, 3) average sized paragraphs.
Begin by making a very short narrative of the data gathering process or
a very short description of the locale or phenomenon. (E,g,
talk about media, or solid waste management…) That’s just a couple of sentences. Follow this with: “The researchers conclude that (affirm the
thesis statement). Furthermore, this is
supported by the following: provide a
summary of the findings as they answer the sub questions. You may modify the wording, just follow the
gist. One principle to take note is that
the conclusion should clearly and directly answer the statement of the
problem. They should match. This is done in discussion format, where you
address questions with answers in paragraph form (in contrast to the statement
of the problem which was in paragraph followed by list).
Recommendations
In writing the recommendations,
you don’t use subheadings. But make sure
that you have distinct paragraphs.
So what do you recommend? There are at least some classes that I can
name. Theories, Norms, Procedures, New
Researches, and Policy.
Theories: are new ideas
that you found from the analyzed data.
Some are modifications to theories.
Some are suggestions to further analyze and test the theory as
previously mentioned in Chapter 1. This
is the pinnacle of humanities research writers.
Norms: are suggested social guidelines regarding a particular
topic. They may also include new values
and goals for groups of people.
E.g. New Vision Mission for
organizations, new values for residents.
Again, these should be based on the findings.
Procedures: are suggested new practices for people. Again, based on findings, are suggested means
to accomplish desired results. Some of
you might have asked “how questions”
these procedures can be helpful to people and organizations, mostly
mentioned in the Significance of the Study.
New Researches: are suggestions for further research on the topic.
Some of these are based on your limitations, some based on what you did not do
in the methodology (if you are quali, you can suggest a quanti – note why?). Some might be based on new ideas that came
out while gathering data.
Policy: as social scientists, this is the pinnacle of research. What new policies can you suggest to the
government? Why? Again this is based on the data you found.
The writing of the recommendation
is in paragraph discussion, where you make your suggestions to x, and justify
them. DO BOT JUST GIVE SIMPLE
SUGGESTIONS, make sure you discuss and justify clear and in detail.
Wednesday, March 13, 2019
Writing Chapter IV: Presentation and Analysis of Data (part 1)
Important note: Since my advisees come from various disciplines, pls exercise critical thinking. These guides are meant to help you compose the content for particular chapters. I'm using a generic system, e.g. Chapter IV is Presentation and Analysis of Data. In some disciplines it's a different number. Just think critically.
On this topic. how to write your presentation of Data.
First off, you need to have treated you raw information first. These are encoded (in MS Excel) survey results for quantitative. And transcriptions (in MS Word) for qualitative.
QUALITATIVE TREATMENT
Transcriptions should have participant profiles at the beginning of the page just right before the actual transcription of the recording. These include code name, what is this resource person (work/ affiliation) and other demographics (age, gender, etc.) that are RELEVANT to the study. Again, only the RELEVANT ones.
Thematiing
The usual step in analysis qualitative data is through thematization of the statements.
Once transcribed, you subject the statements into the 1st stage of analysis called "cool analysis."
Cool analysis is reading and highlighting text that are significant to your research topic. In MS Word, you do this by commenting using the review tool. What comment you write is based on codes. Either you begin with a predertermined set of codes (closed coding) or you just make codes as you progress (open coding). Closed codes are used in phenomenology, narrative, and case study research designs. Open coding is mainly used in grounded theory.
For your thesis you will both use closed and open codes. The closed codes are themes that come from the conceptual framework. That's why it's called a 'framework.' It frames the thesis. And Chapter IV is the part which contains the actual body of data o the thesis. You will also use open codes because, there will always be new information.
So, what's happening is, you are affirming the theory by checking out if the field does match the concepts of the theory. Then, you add to, if there is any new information. Remember, the conceptual framework was guided by the theory you proposed to use in the previous chapters. Here is the part where you check if the theory is true or false, or if there is any twist to the theory since you have conducted a new research.
After reading and highlighting, you reread the material, and align the codes you used. e.g. You might have used the word "development" once, and realized that on the next set of highlights, you used the word "growth" as a code. And you realize that the actual term you want to use is development. So you check them. This is already warm analysis.
Instead of simply using MS Word, you could use MaxQDA or any other software. I, for one, use MaxQDA. It will not think for you, but it will help in processing the highlighted data with codes and lines of connections, and even summary lists of codes and their respective quotes. You can see me in person for MaxQDA basic learning.
Once done with the warm analysis, you harvest the highlighted statements by copy pasting each statement segment to an excel file.
You will have around 3 - 4 columns. 1st column is the transcription source. Best is to fix the way you classify the source. E.g. Brgy Chair 1 (code name) Ambassador 2 (code name) Ambassador 1 (code name). This will help you sort them one everything is in the excel.
2nd Column is the quote or statement segment. It can be a sentence or part of it, or a paragraph. It depends on how significant it is.
3rd column will be the corresponding theme.
4th column will be based on another set of analysis. 4th column may or may not be optional. It depends on the data. One sample is, as you look at all the themes, you might find that some themes belong to a superset or category, so, classify them as such. e.g. themes are fine, award, warning, compliant, subversive, brgy, women's association. You classify fine, award, and warning under "responses."
Sometimes, the reverse is what's happening with the data, you will notice, that there are sub-categories under one theme, that you just create as you reread the excel file. You just do so. Hence, under fine, you can make specifics such as 500, 1,000.
The Simulacrum
You don't put the excel file or even a short version of it into the Chapter IV. What you put there is the illustration of the idea, or a simulacrum. In your thesis, it will be a repeat of your conceptual framework, but this time, with modifications. This is because you were able to find new things from the field which either 1) change the framework into something different, or 2) modify the framework with new or additional concepts. There will also be a possibility of several simulacra to come out of your analysis.
PRESENTING THE DATA
This will be how you write chapter IV. The outline will be based on your conceptual framework. Remember, I asked you to tabulate it's concepts with the statement of the problem along with the questionnaire questions.
Hence the outline, generically is. Begin by talking about the simulacra. How many are there? You don't discuss by pointing out the simulacra. You discuss in terms of what are each simulacra about.
As an example. You might have only one simulacra, which is your conceptual framework as applied to your locale. Proceed with it. Make a heading, title it as aligned on what the simulacrum is about. Sometimes, you have more than one simulacrum. E.g. One simulacrum shows the process on how lgbtq organizations influence the political actions of lawmakers. While another simulacrum shows problems encountered by these orgaizations. If this is the case you introduce the chapter by giving a summary list of the general topics wich are what each topic of the simulacra are about.
So, if you have one simulacrum, introduce it. If more than one, make an introduction covering them all, you will not discuss in full. You will give the reader a eneral idea that you have x topics to go over as you progress in the chapter.
Once done introducing, discuss the the simulacrum in full. What is it about. And then follow this with sub-headings. Each subheading corresponding to each part of the simulacrum. E.g. if the simulacrum is about how new infrastructure in rivers affect the lives of fisherfolk, and it shows: a) economic (with sub-theme of * business and * household), safety, and social relations (sub-theme of *inter-fisher folk, *fisher folk and government, * fisher folk and non-government.) Then these will be the same sub-headings. And you will fully, clearly, and in detail, explain each of this. Give examples coming from the field. You describe the life in the field based on these. Then you support what you describe with evidences.
Evidences will be in the form of pictures (pictures from the field, pictures of documents, pictures of conversations), and quotes (the statements that match each of the codes or themes when you thematized ).
Repeat the process with every simulacrum.
You also insert the diagrams of the simulacrum into Chapter IV. Label appropriately, and in the discussions, refer to them. e.g. "as an be seen in Figure 4: Problems Encountered by XXXXXX, there are actually 3 classes or problems.
Very important note. Analysis does not only mean that you thematize only the transcribed files. You can also include there pictures and documents. E.g. you can quote from public documents. or a certain idea from a picture matches a certain theme.
Analysis of Data
Simply presenting the data is not enough. Panel reviewers will look for your analysis. The cool and warm analysis you made earlier is not the full analysis. At that time, you were simply making sense of the text. Now, you have to make sense of the situation in terms of addressing your statement of the problem.
Obviously, the statement of the problem provides the next set of outline for this area of Chapter IV. And no, you don't make the questions into sub-headings. You make single statement answers to the quetions, and make those your sub-headings.
E.g. Your sub-questions are: What other institutions help the barangay in flood mitigation? How do these institutions interact with each other? Based on that, your sub-headings will be:
The 3 Institutions of Succesful Barangay Flood Mitigation
and
Strong Barangay-NGO Partnerships Towards Flood Mitigation
or
Two-Way Network Flow of Resources on Flood Mitigation
Then you discuss each, and again, be clear, be detailed, use samples, paint a clear picture, use evidence, and, also refer to the simulacrum.
The sequence though will be
1st sub question
next
next
last- subquestion
Then the thesis statement (which is the answer to your main statement of the problem).
I hope this was clear enough. But for questions, pls comment here. Don't pm. And don't ever say it's clear when it's not and your just being shy!!!
On this topic. how to write your presentation of Data.
First off, you need to have treated you raw information first. These are encoded (in MS Excel) survey results for quantitative. And transcriptions (in MS Word) for qualitative.
QUALITATIVE TREATMENT
Transcriptions should have participant profiles at the beginning of the page just right before the actual transcription of the recording. These include code name, what is this resource person (work/ affiliation) and other demographics (age, gender, etc.) that are RELEVANT to the study. Again, only the RELEVANT ones.
Thematiing
The usual step in analysis qualitative data is through thematization of the statements.
Once transcribed, you subject the statements into the 1st stage of analysis called "cool analysis."
Cool analysis is reading and highlighting text that are significant to your research topic. In MS Word, you do this by commenting using the review tool. What comment you write is based on codes. Either you begin with a predertermined set of codes (closed coding) or you just make codes as you progress (open coding). Closed codes are used in phenomenology, narrative, and case study research designs. Open coding is mainly used in grounded theory.
For your thesis you will both use closed and open codes. The closed codes are themes that come from the conceptual framework. That's why it's called a 'framework.' It frames the thesis. And Chapter IV is the part which contains the actual body of data o the thesis. You will also use open codes because, there will always be new information.
So, what's happening is, you are affirming the theory by checking out if the field does match the concepts of the theory. Then, you add to, if there is any new information. Remember, the conceptual framework was guided by the theory you proposed to use in the previous chapters. Here is the part where you check if the theory is true or false, or if there is any twist to the theory since you have conducted a new research.
After reading and highlighting, you reread the material, and align the codes you used. e.g. You might have used the word "development" once, and realized that on the next set of highlights, you used the word "growth" as a code. And you realize that the actual term you want to use is development. So you check them. This is already warm analysis.
Instead of simply using MS Word, you could use MaxQDA or any other software. I, for one, use MaxQDA. It will not think for you, but it will help in processing the highlighted data with codes and lines of connections, and even summary lists of codes and their respective quotes. You can see me in person for MaxQDA basic learning.
| Sample Excel tabulation of themes. Notice that I've added filter tools to the headings of the top row. Those help in sorting the date. It will arrange them based on theme, sub-theme, etc. |
Once done with the warm analysis, you harvest the highlighted statements by copy pasting each statement segment to an excel file.
You will have around 3 - 4 columns. 1st column is the transcription source. Best is to fix the way you classify the source. E.g. Brgy Chair 1 (code name) Ambassador 2 (code name) Ambassador 1 (code name). This will help you sort them one everything is in the excel.
2nd Column is the quote or statement segment. It can be a sentence or part of it, or a paragraph. It depends on how significant it is.
3rd column will be the corresponding theme.
4th column will be based on another set of analysis. 4th column may or may not be optional. It depends on the data. One sample is, as you look at all the themes, you might find that some themes belong to a superset or category, so, classify them as such. e.g. themes are fine, award, warning, compliant, subversive, brgy, women's association. You classify fine, award, and warning under "responses."
Sometimes, the reverse is what's happening with the data, you will notice, that there are sub-categories under one theme, that you just create as you reread the excel file. You just do so. Hence, under fine, you can make specifics such as 500, 1,000.
The Simulacrum
You don't put the excel file or even a short version of it into the Chapter IV. What you put there is the illustration of the idea, or a simulacrum. In your thesis, it will be a repeat of your conceptual framework, but this time, with modifications. This is because you were able to find new things from the field which either 1) change the framework into something different, or 2) modify the framework with new or additional concepts. There will also be a possibility of several simulacra to come out of your analysis.
| Sample Framework as used in the paper I presented in Thailand |
| Sample Simulacrum as used in the paper I presented in Thailand. Notice the similarity and difference with the framework. |
PRESENTING THE DATA
This will be how you write chapter IV. The outline will be based on your conceptual framework. Remember, I asked you to tabulate it's concepts with the statement of the problem along with the questionnaire questions.
Hence the outline, generically is. Begin by talking about the simulacra. How many are there? You don't discuss by pointing out the simulacra. You discuss in terms of what are each simulacra about.
As an example. You might have only one simulacra, which is your conceptual framework as applied to your locale. Proceed with it. Make a heading, title it as aligned on what the simulacrum is about. Sometimes, you have more than one simulacrum. E.g. One simulacrum shows the process on how lgbtq organizations influence the political actions of lawmakers. While another simulacrum shows problems encountered by these orgaizations. If this is the case you introduce the chapter by giving a summary list of the general topics wich are what each topic of the simulacra are about.
So, if you have one simulacrum, introduce it. If more than one, make an introduction covering them all, you will not discuss in full. You will give the reader a eneral idea that you have x topics to go over as you progress in the chapter.
Once done introducing, discuss the the simulacrum in full. What is it about. And then follow this with sub-headings. Each subheading corresponding to each part of the simulacrum. E.g. if the simulacrum is about how new infrastructure in rivers affect the lives of fisherfolk, and it shows: a) economic (with sub-theme of * business and * household), safety, and social relations (sub-theme of *inter-fisher folk, *fisher folk and government, * fisher folk and non-government.) Then these will be the same sub-headings. And you will fully, clearly, and in detail, explain each of this. Give examples coming from the field. You describe the life in the field based on these. Then you support what you describe with evidences.
Evidences will be in the form of pictures (pictures from the field, pictures of documents, pictures of conversations), and quotes (the statements that match each of the codes or themes when you thematized ).
Repeat the process with every simulacrum.
You also insert the diagrams of the simulacrum into Chapter IV. Label appropriately, and in the discussions, refer to them. e.g. "as an be seen in Figure 4: Problems Encountered by XXXXXX, there are actually 3 classes or problems.
Very important note. Analysis does not only mean that you thematize only the transcribed files. You can also include there pictures and documents. E.g. you can quote from public documents. or a certain idea from a picture matches a certain theme.
Analysis of Data
Simply presenting the data is not enough. Panel reviewers will look for your analysis. The cool and warm analysis you made earlier is not the full analysis. At that time, you were simply making sense of the text. Now, you have to make sense of the situation in terms of addressing your statement of the problem.
Obviously, the statement of the problem provides the next set of outline for this area of Chapter IV. And no, you don't make the questions into sub-headings. You make single statement answers to the quetions, and make those your sub-headings.
E.g. Your sub-questions are: What other institutions help the barangay in flood mitigation? How do these institutions interact with each other? Based on that, your sub-headings will be:
The 3 Institutions of Succesful Barangay Flood Mitigation
and
Strong Barangay-NGO Partnerships Towards Flood Mitigation
or
Two-Way Network Flow of Resources on Flood Mitigation
Then you discuss each, and again, be clear, be detailed, use samples, paint a clear picture, use evidence, and, also refer to the simulacrum.
The sequence though will be
1st sub question
next
next
last- subquestion
Then the thesis statement (which is the answer to your main statement of the problem).
I hope this was clear enough. But for questions, pls comment here. Don't pm. And don't ever say it's clear when it's not and your just being shy!!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)